Join Us For

The Lenny's Experience

Traditional Coal-Fired Pizza & More!
View the Menu
Lenny's

November

Pizza of the Month

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

ranch base, grilled chicken with buffalo sauce and mozzarella, ranch, buffalo sauce, green onions

13" Pizza
Our Story

The Lenny's Experience Is
A Joyride For Your Senses

Lenny’s coal fired pizza, brought to you by Costas Restaurant Group, is Valparaiso’s newest and most unique pizza restaurant. Inspired by iconic pizza restaurants in New Haven, Connecticut, Lenny’s brings a taste of the east coast to Valpo. The 70s come back to life in our newly renovated restaurant. We feature tasty wings, pasta and salads in addition to Northwest Indiana’s only coal fired pizza. Come on in and find out why Locals Love Lennys!

Our Story

The Lenny's Experience Is A Joyride For Your Senses

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat. Duis aute irure dolor in reprehenderit in voluptate velit esse cillum dolore eu fugiat nulla pariatur. Excepteur sint occaecat cupidatat non proident, sunt in culpa qui officia deserunt mollit anim id est laborum.
Discover More
Our Most Popular

Coal-Fired Pizzas

New Haven, Connecticut is the pizza capital of America. New Haven-style coal-fired A’pizza carries with it an expectation of char. A’pizza is usually baked to a point where the edges are blackened. All coal fired pizzas are 13”

MOZZARELLA PIE VEGETARIAN
$16

Tomato sauce, mozzarella, Romano
sub 12” cauliflower crust $4

NEW HAVEN TOMATO PIE VEGETARIAN
$15

Tomato sauce, Romano, fresh basil (without mozzarella)

WHITE PIE BASE VEGETARIAN
$17

EVOO, garlic, Romano, mozzarella, ricotta, basil

LENNY’S PIE
$19

Tomato sauce, pepperoni, fresh jalapeño, fresh mozzarella, honey, and goat cheese

MICHAEL’S WHITE PIE
$18

EVOO, garlic, Romano, mozzarella, Ricotta, ham, mushrooms, spinach

BBQ CHICKEN
$19

BBQ sauce, mozzarella, chicken, red onion, ranch, green onions

GARDEN PIE VEGETARIAN
$18

Tomato sauce, mozzarella, Romano, onion, mushroom, roasted red pepper, spinach

PESTO CHICKEN PIE
$19

Pesto sauce, fresh mozzarella, chicken, spinach, cherry tomatoes, red onion garnish

SUPREME PIE
$19

Tomato sauce, Italian sausage, green pepper, red onion, mushroom

B.Y.O. Calzone
$12

Filled with mozzarella and your choice of pizza toppings for $1.75 each. Served with a side of marinara

ADDITIONAL TOPPINGS - $1.95 EACH

Sausage • Pepperoni • Bacon • Ham • Green Peppers
Roasted Red Pepper • Red Onion • Mushroom
Pineapple • Tomato • Olive • Jalapeño • Goat Cheese

Our Menu

À la Carte

Salads
CAESAR SALAD GLUTEN FREE
$12

Romaine, house croutons, grated parmesan, black pepper, tossed with Caesar dressing.

HOUSE SALAD
$10

Seasonal greens, cherry tomatoes, english cucumbers, grated parmesan, choice of dressing.

BEET SALAD VEGETARIAN & GF
$14

Spinach & arugula, pickled beets, red onion, oranges, kalamata olives, walnuts, goat cheese, craisins, side of citrus vinaigrette.

GREEK VILLAGE SALAD VEGETARIAN & GF
$14

Tomato, cucumber, green peppers, kalamata olives, red onion, feta, tossed in a Greek herb & oil dressing.

Cobb Salad
$14

Spinach & romaine, bacon, hard boiled egg, tomato, onion, croutons, blue cheese, avocado, onion, side of avocado ranch.

Starters
BUFFALO FRIES
$12

Fries, diced buffalo chicken, blue cheese, ranch, chives.

Pickle Fries
$11

Hand-battered fried pickle spears, served with a side of ranch.

BRUSCHETTA VEGETARIAN
$10

Tomato, basil, balsamic, Romano.

MEATBALLS
$13

Italian sausage and USDA prime beef. Marinara, Romano, ricotta, and parsley.

GARLIC BREAD VEGETARIAN
$6

Make it cheesy $2

Wings
Wings (8)
$14

DRY RUBS: Lemon Pepper, Nashville Hot, Honey Garlic
SAUCES: BBQ, Buffalo, Garlic Parmesan

sandwiches
Philly Beef
$16

Philly steak, grilled onions and peppers, mozzarella, on a hoagie roll

Meatball Sub
$15

Meatballs, mozzarella, parsley, served on a hoagie roll

BLTA
$14

Bacon, lettuce, tomato, avocado, mayo, mozzarella, tomatoes on panini.

Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich
$18

Fried chicken sandwich, pickles, lettuce, Nashville hot sauce, served on a potato bun

Double Smash Burger
$17

Double Patties On A Potato Bun with American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Grilled Onions, Pickle Spears, and Lenny's Special Homemade Sauce.

Entrees
SHRIMP SCAMPI
$18

Thin spaghetti noodles, garlic, wine reduction, red pepper flakes and parsley, served with garlic bread.

CHICKEN & BROCCOLI ALFREDO
$16

Thin spaghetti noodles, creamy house made alfredo sauce, parmesan, parsley, served with garlic bread.

SPAGHETTI & MEATBALLS
$16

Thin spaghetti noodles served with marinara & meatballs and topped with basil chiffonade. Served with garlic bread.
SPAGHETTI & RED SAUCE ONLY - $11

sides
Fries
$5
SIDE SALAD
$5
SOUP OF THE DAY
$5
drinks
coke products
$3.50
SPARKLING WATER
$3.50
ICED TEA
$3.50
LEMONADE
$3.50
View Full Menu
Order Takeout
Order Delivery
Close
© 2023 Lenny's Coal-Fired Pizza | JWM Marketing & Web Design
3800 N Calumet Ave, Valparaiso, IN 46383
(219) 312-7882
Close